Theme | Sub-theme | Role Play (RP) | Video-Based Learning (VBL) |
---|---|---|---|
Effective Communication | Communication Skills | Enhanced confidence and reduced hesitation during public speaking. “We gained a lot of knowledge and confidence for effective communication in the hospital.” | Improved understanding of communication with patients, seniors, and juniors. “We learned how to communicate with others, patients, seniors.” |
Knowledge Gain | Promoted active learning through hands-on, experiential activities. | Provided structured insights into hospital communication scenarios. | |
Positive Learning | Faculty guidance and interactive sessions created a comfortable and engaging environment. “It was a positive experience learning from good faculty in a comfortable environment.” | Informative and visually structured teaching method appreciated by participants. | |
Overcoming Hesitation | Helped participants overcome fear of speaking in group settings and develop confidence. “I think it was a very good opportunity. My communication skills and my confidence have boosted up.” | Less impactful for reducing hesitation due to passive nature of watching videos. “The videos were quite beneficial, but there was a lot of passive learning and not many interactive sessions” | |
Reducing Gaps | Promoted better understanding between doctors and nurses, fostering collaboration. “Interacting with nurses helped us understand each other and support our patients better.” | Emphasized improving communication for patient outcomes. “We learnt how improving communication between doctor and staff can enhance patient outcomes.” | |
Teaching Methodology | Identifying Mistakes | Highlighted and corrected communication errors through live feedback. “We could observe each other’s mistakes and give feedback” | Encouraged recognition of communication gaps via video examples. “The videos helped to recognize mistakes and promptly acting by communicating and bringing issues to the doctor’s notice.” |
Practical Application | Demonstrated skills applicable in ward settings and real-world scenarios. “It will help us utilise these skills in our wards.” | Demonstrated theoretical communication scenarios with limited real-world applicability. | |
OSCE Relevance | Participants noted relevance of RP to future OSCE performance. “It can help us improve our performance in OSCEs” | Suggested incorporating communication skills into OSCE through VBL examples. “The examples used in the videos can definitely be used in OSCE exams for communication skills.” | |
Perceived Challenges | Language Barriers | Addressed interprofessional communication struggles but highlighted lack of multilingual support. “We should have scenarios in different languages because those situations can be challenging.” | Identified language as a significant obstacle. “Language can be a barrier between doctor, patient, and staff.” |
Past Experience | Difficulties faced during first-time interaction with nurses and staff. “First-time interaction with nurses was challenging.” | ||
Time and Focus | Participants applauded the role-play scenarios for efficiency. “It takes a little time and a was easy to concentrate.” | Timing issues noted in videos, reducing focus and engagement. “Timing can be improved in the videos.” | |
Suggestions for Improvement | Practical Experience | Recommended extending role-play activities to include real patient interaction. “… real patient interactions can improve awareness of symptoms.” | Suggested integrating videos with practical, hands-on sessions for better applicability. “More practical experience with direct patient interaction.” |
Workshop Frequency | Advocated for more frequent role-play workshops to reinforce skills. “We need such sessions regularly to solidify our skills.” | Suggested regular workshops to maintain communication proficiency. “Continuous practice with workshops can improve communication.” | |
Scenario Diversity | Suggested incorporating diverse clinical scenarios in role-play exercises. “More examples and different scenarios will help us get more broad knowledge.” | Recommended covering a wider range of medical cases and symptoms. “The more variety of cases we can include, the better it will be for our learning.” |